Exploring Adaptive Reuse as a Sustainability Strategy

Feb. 2, 2024
Sean Farney, Vice President of Data Center Strategy for the Americas at JLL, explains why it's time to gamify circularity with carbon accounting credits.

Just south of Chicago’s central business district sits Digital Realty's storied 350 East Cermak data center. As one of the original carrier hotels, the building serves as a vital nerve center for data flowing in and out of the city. But what makes the building so interesting to me is the grand library on the top floor. I think it’s the prettiest data hall in the world.

A library is the original data center; we’ve stored the history of humanity in racks and cabinets for thousands of years. However, we likely wouldn’t discover one sitting atop floors full of servers if 350 East Cermak wasn’t a historic building. The facility is one of many successful adaptive reuse projects showcasing how developers can transform yesterday’s centers of commerce into today’s critical infrastructure.

With sustainability becoming increasingly important, redeveloping older buildings can be a powerful way to reduce a building’s carbon footprint and meet mounting demand for new data centers.

Understanding the sustainable promise of adaptive reuse  

Data center size, importance and complexity have increased in recent years, driving a reliance on net new facility builds. Both the required time-to-revenue and certainty of technical performance have often driven out the desire for “recycling” older buildings.

Our throwaway culture has led the industry to believe that newness is better, but that’s not always true. As we've quietly taken adaptive reuse off the table in the interest of perceived risk and speed, we've added massively to environmental impact, chiefly in the form of concrete and steel embodied carbon.

With a circular mindset, any commercial building with the right bones and sufficient power supply can be transformed into a data center. Off the top of my head, I can rattle off at least a half dozen examples, stretching from 60 Hudson in New York to One Wilshire in Los Angeles. In Dallas, DataBank’s downtown data center and headquarters occupies a former Federal Reserve Building. Then there’s the iconic Switch Pyramid in Grand Rapids, Michigan. The unique building housed a furniture research and design facility until Switch acquired and redeveloped it as a data center.

The data center industry can even give vacant retail spaces a new purpose. For example, in 2012, edge data center company Ubiquity Critical Environments sought to leverage the massive 250 million-square-foot Sears and Kmart real estate portfolio to house a network of connected edge sites in second and third-tier markets.

Combatting throwaway culture

Given the immense potential of adaptive reuse, why does it continue to be such a missed opportunity? I believe it’s because we lack a true line of sight into the carbon savings of adaptive reuse and, therefore, incentive.

I propose we measure both the embodied carbon used in the original construction and the embodied carbon avoided in not building new. That includes not just concrete and steel but the entire construction value chain: manufacturing, shipping, installation, building and even the act of not paving over a new site. 

Armed with these numbers, we need to gamify adaptive reuse — just like how introducing power usage effectiveness (PUE) brought sustainability competition to the industry. Imagine how behavior would change if we issued a carbon accounting credit to companies that make the circular choice to recycle a building.

Why now is the time to invest in adaptive reuse

The accelerating trajectory of the data center build pipeline not only has a huge carbon footprint, but it also outpaces the inventory of sites with power and the supply chain to erect new structures on them. 

This land-and-power war is exacerbated by public commitments to shareholders to deliver both revenue and capacity. Add new artificial intelligence (AI) demand to this already constrained market, and we have a severe shortfall.

Mark Ganzi, CEO of Digital Bridge, estimates AI will require 38GW of accretive digital infrastructure demand. If the industry met just 10% of that demand with adaptive reuse and modular deployment, we could recycle and future-fit 380 buildings (assuming 10MW per 10,000 square feet for high-density AI facilities). And with 30 billion square feet of commercial real estate in the US alone, there’s no shortage of applicable sites.

Not only does adaptive reuse lead to massive carbon savings, but it also can reduce time-to-revenue and improve the efficient utilization of stranded power. It’s time to bring new thinking to data center development — a mindset that embraces the old in the name of innovation. It’s just smart. And as 350 East Cermak has shown us, it can be beautiful, too.

About the Author

Sean Farney

As Vice President of Data Center Strategy for the Americas at JLL, Sean Farney helps clients operate more than 900 data centers sustainably and efficiently. Prior roles include Director of Data Center Marketing at Kohler, Founder and Chief Operating Officer at Edge data center startup of Ubiquity Critical Environments, and data center manager for Microsoft’s 120MW Chicago facility.   

Sean strives to embody sustainability personally; he hunts, grows, or harvests a majority of his food and burns deadfall to heat his home, earning him a county-leading Energy Star rating. He holds a master’s degree in Information Technology from Northwestern University.

Contact JLL to learn more about how it helps build, buy, occupy, and invest in a variety of assets, including data centers,  globally.

Sponsored Recommendations

Get Utility Project Solutions

Lightweight, durable fiberglass conduit provides engineering benefits, performance and drives savings for successful utility project outcomes.

Guide to Environmental Sustainability Metrics for Data Centers

Unlock the power of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) reporting in the data center industry with our comprehensive guide, proposing 28 key metrics across five categories...

The AI Disruption: Challenges and Guidance for Data Center Design

From large training clusters to small edge inference servers, AI is becoming a larger percentage of data center workloads. Learn more.

A better approach to boost data center capacity – Supply capacity agreements

Explore a transformative approach to data center capacity planning with insights on supply capacity agreements, addressing the impact of COVID-19, the AI race, and the evolving...

LookerStudio/Shutterstock.com

The Competitive Edge of Enterprise Edge

Brett Lindsey, CEO ark data centers, explains why edge data centers will become increasingly vital, making them the cornerstone of digital transformation strategies for enterprises...

White Papers

Dcf Venyu Wp Cover 2021 07 12 7 15 51 233x300

The Business Case for Data Center Geo Diversity

July 13, 2022
Geo diversity, or shortening the distance that your data travels, will allow you to reaching your user bases more effectively, and create better customer experiences. This white...